Transportation Law · October 26, 2026
A Freight Broker's Forum Selection Clause Holds Up in the EDNY: Atlantic Wells v. AG Carrier
On October 17, 2026, the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of New York enforced a Florida freight broker's Broward County forum selection clause and dismissed the broker from a cargo-damage suit on a Rule 12(b)(6) motion. The court applied the Second Circuit's four-part Phillips v. Audio Active Ltd. test, held the clause reasonably communicated, mandatory, and broad enough to reach a negligent-selection tort claim because the broker's duty to select a transporter arose from the contract itself, and found no rebuttal. Nine practice pointers for Florida transportation lawyers and freight brokers on drafting mandatory language, wide scope language, pairing with choice of law, electronic signature audit trails, and venue selection. Black Law P.A.'s Cody Shilling represented the broker.
Read the article →