On October 17, 2026, in Atlantic Wells, Inc. v. AG Carrier, LLC and United States of Freight, LLC, No. 2:25-cv-02924 (ENV)(AYS), U.S. District Judge Eric N. Vitaliano of the Eastern District of New York dismissed a Florida freight broker from a cargo-damage lawsuit based on a forum selection clause in the parties’ Carrier-Broker Agreement. The clause required any dispute to be brought in Broward County, Florida. The court applied the Second Circuit’s four-part Phillips test, found the clause reasonably communicated, mandatory, and broad enough to reach a tort claim, and granted the broker’s Rule 12(b)(6) motion without prejudice. The plaintiff’s claim against the motor carrier remains before the EDNY.
For Florida freight brokers and the lawyers who draft their shipping contracts, the opinion is a clean reminder that a well-written forum selection clause can resolve a case before discovery. For plaintiffs who think they can avoid such a clause by styling their claim as a tort rather than a breach of contract, the decision is a reminder that courts in the Second Circuit (and most others) look at substance, not labels.
Black Law P.A.’s Cody Shilling represented the freight broker and obtained the dismissal.
The Facts
Atlantic Wells, Inc., a buyer of commercial trucks, engaged United States of Freight, LLC (USF), a Florida-based freight broker, to arrange the interstate transport of a 2002 Freightliner FL112 crane truck purchased in Virginia for $75,000. USF retained AG Carrier, LLC, a South Carolina-based motor carrier, to perform the actual shipment. On or about August 10, 2024, AG Carrier’s driver struck an overhead obstruction en route from Virginia to New York, damaging the truck. The carrier’s insurer denied coverage. Atlantic Wells sued both the broker (for negligent selection and hiring) and the carrier (for negligence) in Suffolk County Supreme Court. USF removed the action to the Eastern District of New York on diversity jurisdiction and moved to dismiss under Rule 12(b)(6), invoking the forum selection clause in the Carrier-Broker Agreement.
The Forum Selection Clause
The Carrier-Broker Agreement was a two-page electronic document. Page one carried the shipment details, pricing, and signature block. Page two carried the terms and conditions. The forum selection provision, in standard font on page two, read in full:
“Any dispute arising between Broker and Customer arising out of these terms and conditions shall be governed by the substantive and procedural law of the State of Florida; Florida law shall apply in all instances. Any lawsuit or legal proceeding arising out of these terms and conditions and/or the services provided must be brought in courts located within Broward County Florida.”
Daniel Hawxhurst, an officer of Atlantic Wells, had executed the agreement electronically on July 26, 2024. The e-signature carried a timestamp and an IP address.
The Phillips Four-Part Test
In the Second Circuit, a court evaluating a forum selection clause walks through the four factors laid out in Phillips v. Audio Active Ltd., 494 F.3d 378 (2d Cir. 2007):
- Was the clause reasonably communicated to the party resisting enforcement?
- Is the clause mandatory or permissive?
- Are the claims and parties involved in the suit within the scope of the clause?
- If the first three factors are satisfied, the clause is presumptively enforceable, and the party resisting it must make a sufficiently strong showing that enforcement would be unreasonable or unjust, or that the clause was invalid for reasons such as fraud or overreaching.
Judge Vitaliano found all three affirmative factors satisfied, and the plaintiff’s rebuttal fell short on each of the four permissible grounds. Each stage of the analysis has a transportation-practice takeaway.
Reasonably Communicated: Electronic Contracting Done Right
The court held the clause reasonably communicated because it appeared in standard font in the main body of a short, clearly structured electronic contract. The two-page format mattered. Page one surfaced the business terms. Page two carried the legal terms. There was no suggestion that the signatory had been prevented from seeing or reviewing either page before clicking through. The electronic signature’s timestamp and IP address were cited as additional indicia that the agreement was executed knowingly.
For brokers using electronic contracting platforms, the lesson is operational. Keep the agreement short enough to read. Keep the forum selection clause on a page the signatory has to see. Preserve the signature audit trail (timestamp, IP, and session metadata) so that if the clause is ever challenged, the court does not need to guess at how the signatory interacted with the document. The plaintiff here submitted an affidavit from the signer in opposition to the motion to dismiss, but Judge Vitaliano declined to consider it because the affidavit was not integral to the complaint. The court decided the motion on the four corners of the contract and the complaint.
Mandatory, Not Permissive
The clause used the word “must.” That one word carried the second Phillips factor. The Second Circuit distinguishes mandatory from permissive forum selection clauses based on whether the designated forum is exclusive or merely available. “Must,” “shall,” and “exclusive jurisdiction” drive the clause into the mandatory column. “May,” “consent to jurisdiction,” and similar permissive language do not. See Global Seafood Inc. v. Bantry Bay Mussels Ltd., 659 F.3d 221, 225 (2d Cir. 2011).
Brokers and transportation lawyers drafting new agreements should audit existing templates for permissive language. Any instance of “may be brought in,” “consent to jurisdiction in,” or “are subject to the jurisdiction of” a particular court is an invitation for a plaintiff to sue elsewhere. Rewrite to “must be brought in” or “shall be brought exclusively in.”
Scope: The Tort Claim That Could Not Escape the Contract
This is the most important doctrinal piece of the opinion for freight-broker defense. The plaintiff did not plead a breach-of-contract claim against USF. It pleaded negligent selection and hiring, a classic tort theory used against brokers to attack their vetting of motor carriers. On paper, that claim does not depend on the Carrier-Broker Agreement. The plaintiff tried to argue it, in substance, was a tort governed by common-law negligence principles that would survive outside the forum clause’s reach.
The court was not persuaded. Second Circuit law looks past labels and asks whether the claim “originates from a right or duty under the agreement.” As Judge Vitaliano put it, “the contract is still the source of the tort duty that Atlantic Wells seeks to enforce, because USF’s obligation to select and hire a transporter itself arose out of the contract.” The Carrier-Broker Agreement expressly provided that the broker “will obtain the services of a freight transporter with the ability and qualifications to move and deliver my freight.” The negligent-selection claim was, in substance, an allegation that the broker had not performed that contractual duty well enough. That substance brought the tort claim within the forum clause’s “arising out of these terms and conditions and/or the services provided” language.
The court underscored the point by quoting Weingard v. Telepathy, Inc., No. 05 CIV. 2024 (MBM), 2005 WL 2990645, at *4 (S.D.N.Y. Nov. 7, 2005): “A forum selection clause cannot be defeated by artful pleading of claims not based on the contract containing the clause if those claims grow out of the contractual relationship, or if the gist of those claims is a breach of that relationship.”
For brokers and their lawyers, this is the sentence to put in the file for the next motion. Even a plaintiff who abandons breach-of-contract framing cannot route around a well-drafted scope clause when the duty it is trying to enforce comes from the contract itself. Scope language matters. “Arising out of” is broader than “relating to breach of” and significantly broader than a bare “for breach of this agreement.” Draft wide.
The Rebuttal That Wasn’t
Once the first three Phillips factors are satisfied, the clause is presumptively enforceable. The resisting party can rebut only by showing: (1) fraud or overreaching in the clause’s incorporation; (2) grave inconvenience or unfairness depriving the plaintiff of its day in court; (3) fundamental unfairness in the chosen law; or (4) violation of a strong public policy of the forum state. The party opposing enforcement bears a “heavy burden” of proof. See Cuhadar v. Savoya, LLC, 766 F. Supp. 3d 434, 449–50 (E.D.N.Y. 2025).
Atlantic Wells argued none of them successfully. The complaint contained no allegation that the broker misrepresented the terms, denied that further terms existed, or induced the signatory not to read page two. The plaintiff’s point that the evidence was in New York and the collision had happened outside Florida did not satisfy the grave-inconvenience prong. The plaintiff raised no fundamental unfairness in Florida law and no public policy issue. The clause was enforced.
What the Court Did Not Reach
Because the forum selection ground resolved the motion, the court did not reach USF’s other arguments for dismissal, which included federal preemption (49 U.S.C. § 14501(c)(1) is the usual vehicle for broker-preemption arguments against negligent selection claims), a contractual limitation of liability, contractual preclusion, and the independent tort doctrine. Those arguments live for another day. The point is that a broker with a well-drafted agreement can often avoid the merits altogether. If the forum clause does the work, the preemption fight and the limitation-of-liability fight do not have to happen.
Practice Pointers for Florida Freight Brokers and Transportation Lawyers
- Draft the clause as mandatory. Use “must be brought in” or “shall be brought exclusively in.” Avoid any permissive language that lets a plaintiff argue the designated forum is one option among several.
- Pair the clause with a choice of law. The agreement here coupled Broward County venue with Florida substantive and procedural law. A choice-of-law pairing reduces the plaintiff’s ability to argue that the chosen forum would apply unfavorable law.
- Write scope language wide. “Arising out of these terms and conditions and/or the services provided” was broad enough to capture a negligent-selection tort claim. Narrower language limited to “breaches” or “claims under this agreement” invites litigation about whether the clause reaches the claim at all.
- Keep contracts short and legible. A two-page electronic agreement with the forum clause on page two in standard font passed the reasonable-communication test with ease. A hundred-page terms document with the clause buried in paragraph 73 invites a very different ruling.
- Preserve the e-signature audit trail. The timestamp and IP address on this signature were cited as evidence that the signer had executed the agreement knowingly. Use a platform that preserves and timestamps the signing event, and keep those records with the agreement.
- Specify the shipment details on the signature page. The agreement here recorded the truck’s make and model, its origin and destination, and the cost of shipping. Shipment-specific detail on page one makes it harder for a plaintiff to argue later that the agreement was a general template unrelated to the loss.
- Pick a Florida venue that is business-court friendly. Broward County is a reasonable, high-volume commercial venue. A less common Florida county could invite argument about whether enforcement is unreasonable. Where the broker is Florida-based, Broward, Miami-Dade, Hillsborough, Orange, or Duval are defensible choices.
- Pair the clause with substantive protections. Even brokers with strong forum clauses should keep federal preemption arguments, limitation-of-liability provisions, and independent-tort-doctrine arguments in the agreement and in the motion playbook. A good forum clause usually resolves the case first. The other defenses are there if it does not.
- On the plaintiff side, do the four-part gating analysis before filing anywhere other than the chosen forum. If the clause is reasonably communicated, mandatory, and broad enough to reach the claim, and if none of the four rebuttal grounds is realistically available, the only outcome of filing elsewhere is dismissal and a reset to the chosen forum.
The Bottom Line
Forum selection clauses in freight-broker agreements continue to work when they are drafted carefully, communicated clearly, and written to reach beyond pure breach-of-contract claims. Atlantic Wells v. AG Carrier is a short, practical application of the Second Circuit’s Phillips test by a federal judge who did not need to reach the merits because the contract already answered the question of where the merits had to be litigated. For every Florida freight broker and the lawyers who draft their contracts, the lesson is the one the opinion makes plain: the paper you put in front of the customer on day one does the heavy lifting on the day the suit arrives.
See also: Freight Broker Liability After Montgomery v. Caribe Transport on the Eleventh Circuit’s approach to broker preemption under 49 U.S.C. § 14501(c)(1), which is the companion substantive defense when the forum selection clause does not resolve the case.